More Than One Thousand Symbolic Defections

The NotMe.ie service has now registered more than one thousand symbolic defections, almost all from the Roman Catholic Church. In April 2011 the Catholic Church changed Canon Law to removed the option to record formal defections. This decision caused the CountMeOut.ie service to be closed. That service had been established by Cormac Flynn, Paul Dunbar and Grainne O’Sullivan to facilitate formal defections, but the change to Canon Law made this process impossible. Subsequently, the NotMe.ie service was established by Atheist Ireland to allow at least symbolic defections to continue.

In addition to the people who have used the NotMe.ie service, there has been other pressure applied to the Church in this area. For example, barrister Katherine Finn, a member of Atheist Ireland, has pointed out that there is existing case law underpinning the constitutional right of dissociation. Illustrated below is an extract from her recent letter to the Archbishop of Dublin:

 

Extract from correspondence to the Archdiocese of Dublin from Katherine Finn BL

Extract from correspondence to the Archdiocese of Dublin from Katherine Finn BL

 

These arguments and others have convinced the Archdiocese of Dublin to at least create a ‘Register of de facto Defection’, which is similar to the NotMe.ie service. Anyone who has been baptised in the Archdiocese of Dublin and who no longer considers themselves to be a member of the Roman Catholic Church, is encouraged to both register a symbolic defection on NotMe.ie and also write to the Archdiocese of Dublin in order to be added to their Register of de facto Defection. Illustrated below is an extract from the response from the Archdiocese of Dublin, referring to their Register of de facto Defection:

 

Extract from correspondence from the Archdiocese of Dublin to Katherine Finn BL

Extract from correspondence from the Archdiocese of Dublin to Katherine Finn BL

 

The experience of those wishing to leave the Roman Catholic Church appears to be quite different depending on which diocese they were baptised in. For example, some people requesting excommunication have been facilitated by the Diocese of Down and Connor. In contrast, other people who were baptised in the Diocese of Ossory have had quite different experiences. It seems that it remains possible to formally leave the Roman Catholic Church and to have that decision recorded, but some more persistence is now required that was the case before April 2011. It may be useful to:

  • ask to be added to a Register of de facto Defection
  • if such a register does not exist in your diocese, ask that it should be created
  • ask to be excommunicated based on the Canon on apostasy
  • describe how your apostasy has had a real impact on your life
  • refer to your constitutional right to dissociate from an organisation

The CountMeOut.ie campaign was successful in allowing many people to formally leave the Roman Catholic Church. The NotMe.ie campaign has also achieved some success in registering more than 1,000 symbolic defections, and along with other efforts, precipitating the creation of the Register of de facto Defections within the Archdiocese of Dublin. Atheist Ireland will continue to campaign on these issues.

1 Comment

  1. Avatar
    Richard Cronin May 29, 2018

    Membership numbers in the RCC are based on the census… if you want to have a real effect on the argument from numbers fill out your census correctly

    Reply

Leave reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

NotMe.ie